.png)
Technical Clarification In Response to The Complaint Report
Please check the given figure pictures for the visual informations.
FIGURE 1.1 FIGURE 1.2 FIGURE 1.3 FIGURE 1.4
Material Specification for Transmission Shaft Used in Our Sheaves
Transmission shafts have low carbon content, which ensures high weldability. These shafts are highly resistant to corrosion, so internal pitting or other types of corrosion are not commonly observed. Transmission steels offer excellent resistance to external impacts. They do not break under tensile forces, stretching, or similar stress conditions.
The tensile strength of the ST 37 transmission shafts we use can be understood from their designation. This material has a tensile strength of 370 N/mm². From its pure grade, the yield strength can also be derived. The point at which deformation begins is 235 N/mm².
Tensile strength is defined as the maximum load a material can handle while being stretched or pulled without breaking. Yield strength refers to the maximum stress a material can withstand without experiencing permanent deformation, meaning it cannot return to its original dimensions after this point.
Please check the given Figure 2.
Transmission shafts are widely used in many sectors such as bridge construction, the automotive industry, and the machinery industry due to their high weldability. The transmission shaft shown in the image is an ST 37 transmission shaft. The chemical analysis of the material is provided below.
Please check the given Figure 3.
The required values according to the standards are as follows:
Please check the given Figure 4.
According to the values provided by our supplier, the material is an St 37 transmission shaft. Our opinion is as follows, with further details explained below:
In the video you sent, at the 29th second, we can observe that the rope rotates briefly on the shaft surface, cleaning off the surface corrosion. Since these materials are purchased in production lengths and cut to order sizes using metal saws, the material can be consistently cut with metal blades.
Please check the given Figure 5.
While the elevator was in motion, deflection was observed in the side bearing of the sheave due to an unexpected sudden load, as shown in Figure 1.1, and the upward fracture of the shaft in Figure 1.3 indicates that it was exposed to a sudden change in load. The reaction of the bearing inside the shaft, which appears to have been forced upward, also shows that it was subjected to sudden mechanical stress. Additionally, the deformation seen on the outer diameter of the sheave caused by the rope suggests that the rope was displaced during travel. As visible in the image, due to sudden braking, the rope escaped from the sheave, began moving along the shaft, and caused wear on the side of the sheave, as seen in Figure 1.4.
The images confirm that the shaft could not have fractured spontaneously under normal operating conditions. The elevator may have been exposed to sudden braking, or a malfunction in the machine could have caused a sudden change in load, or the rope flow might not have been adequately maintained. Furthermore, if the bearing had seized, the rope would have continued to rotate over the sheave and caused groove wear, but there is no visible wear in the sheave grooves in any of the four figures. As seen in Figure 1.2, the shaft has clearly fractured in the upward direction; this is not a torsional fracture but a direct break caused by metal cutting and a sudden upward load shift.
To explain the load-bearing capacity of the transmission shaft in more detail, the area of a circle with a radius of 25 units is π x 25² = 1963.4954084936 mm² (π = 3.141592653589793). When calculated:
370 Newtons (N):
1 N = 0.101972 kilograms-force (kgf) → 370 N = 37.7295 kgf
1 kgf = 9.80665 N
235 Newtons (N):
1 N = 0.101972 kilograms-force (kgf) → 235 N = 23.9633 kgf
1 kgf = 9.80665 N
Average yield load = 1963 mm² × 23.96 kgf = 47,009 kg
Tensile strength load = 1963 mm² × 37.72 kgf = 74,006 kg (maximum load the material can bear)
The material’s cross-sectional strength values are calculated as shown above.
When calculating shaft dimensions and thickness, many variables and definitions come into play: moment of inertia, torsional values, bending values, slope calculations (if applicable), vibration values, torsional vibration values, etc. Below is our strength explanation in the simplest terms:
Pulley Shaft Control
T1 = T2 = gn × (P + Q + H)
Tm = 2 × T1
Bending Moment
M = Tm × L / 4
L₀ = 300 mm, distance between two bearings L = 200 mm
Shaft Section Modulus
W = π × d³ / 32
d = 50 mm
W = 12,265 mm³
L = Shaft length between bearings (mm)
d = Shaft diameter (mm)
For transmission steel:
σ₀.₂ = 235 N/mm²
σ₀ = 188 N/mm² = σ_em
Bending Stress
σ_e = M / W = (Tm × L / 4) / W < σ_em = 188 N/mm² must be satisfied.
Tm = 4 × σ_e × W / L
Tm = 4 × 188 × 12,265 / 200
Tm = 46,116.4 N → For loads less than 4,700 kg, this shaft length and diameter are sufficient.
Even at yield point zero, the achieved value is as above.
Shaft Calculation = Heavy Duty Pulley– 2 Pulleys – (P + Q = 2.5 tons) – Shaft Length: 300 mm
T1 = (P + Q + H) × gn
T1 = (2500 + 50) × 9.81 = 25,015 N
T1 = 25,015 / 2 = 12,507 N (because there are 2 pulleys)
T1 = Tm
Tm = 12,507.75 N
Bending Moment
L = 300 mm, distance between two side bearings = 200 mm
M = Tm × (L / 4)
M = 12,507.75 × (200 / 4)
M = 625,350 N·mm
Section Modulus: If Shaft Diameter is 50 mm
W = π × d³ / 32
W = π × (50³) / 32
W = 12,265.62
σ_em = M / W = 625,350 / 12,265.62
σ_em = 50.98 N/mm² < 235 N/mm² (Yield Strength)
Therefore, without a notch (also known as a cut) and a sudden dynamic load, such a fracture is absolutely not possible.
Metallurgical and Materials Engineer
Ferhat SARIMAN